In 1994, owner Al Mauceri began his career in insurance with Nationwide as a Claims Representative in Charlotte, North Carolina. Over the next seven years, Al rose to various management positions until he was promoted to National Claims Director in Columbus, Ohio. At the time, Al was one of the youngest National Claims Directors in the entire industry.
In 2005, Mauceri decided to pursue his dream of owning his own company. He left corporate America and with a laptop, phone, and his sole employee, Melanie Royle, and started the Mauceri Insurance Agency in McKinney, Texas. At that time, the agency only represented Nationwide Insurance.
To be able to provide his clients with the best coverage options possible, Mauceri changed his business model and became an independent broker in 2010. Becoming an independent broker allowed him to expand his capabilities and further tailor the optimal insurance plans for individual customers.
In 2011, Al acquired Bynum Insurance of McKinney, and when their owner retired, the newly merged Mauceri Bynum Insurance became the largest home and auto insurance agency in the city.
Mauceri-Bynum Insurance has gone on to be voted the BEST INSURANCE AGENCY of McKinney from 2014 to 2025. They have an A+ rating from the Better Business Bureau as well as an A rating on Angie's List. Al received the honor of being named on D Magazine's 2018 Best Insurance Agents List, an accomplishment he is incredibly proud of.
The team at Mauceri-Bynum is committed to helping their clients find the right combination of tailored, personalized insurance coverage at just the right price to suit their needs.
Contact Our Team
We invite you to complete an online quote, call us at (214) 733-8400 , or contact us at contact@minsuranceagent.com to review coverage options for your car, home, life, business, renters, boat, and other insurance needs. We provide free, no-hassle and no-obligation insurance quotes to equip you with everything you need to know before you make such an important decision.
Mauceri-Bynum Insurance strives to offer you quality insurance coverage, a high level of professional service, and to build a long-term relationship as your insurance agent. As independent agents in Texas, we'll research rates and coverage from top insurance companies to find the best plan for you. We do the shopping and comparisons to save you time and money!
Contact us or quote yourself online today!
Owner
Office Manager
Sales Manager
In Memory of
Marketing Manager
Account Manager
Account Manager
Account Manager
Account Manager
Account Manager
Account Manager
Account Manager
Account Manager
Client Services
We are a RamseyTrusted insurance ELP located in McKinney, Texas! An endorsement that is earned, not bought.
What's the difference between Mauceri Bynum Insurance and other pros? The RamseyTrusted shield. The Ramsey team knows how we do business and that we will go out of our way to super-serve your needs! #RamseyTrusted
We are able to offer you the same exact rates as going direct, yet we give you access to all of our agents completely free of charge.
Ramsey endorsed agencies WORK FOR YOU not for the insurance companies.
For more information on what it means to be RamseyTrusted follow the link below!
ramseysolutions.com/trusted/what-is-ramseytrustedDon't hesitate to shoot us an email or phone call!
Contact Us!
Best of McKinney 12 Years. In a Row. Unmatched in McKinney.
Mauceri Bynum Insurance has been voted Best of McKinney for 12 straight years—an incredible streak in a city with over 100 insurance agencies. Facilitated by the McKinney Chamber of Commerce, these awards are decided by the people who matter most: our neighbors. Twelve wins in a row isn’t just luck—it’s proof of the trust, care, and expertise we deliver to every client, every day.
Nextdoor Favorite – Trusted by Your Neighbors
Mauceri Bynum Insurance was honored as a Nextdoor Favorite in both 2022 and 2024, reflecting the trust and appreciation of the local community. Being recognized by neighbors on a platform built for connecting residents is especially meaningful. It shows that our commitment to personalized service, transparency, and reliable insurance solutions truly makes a difference in the lives of the people we serve.
BusinessRate Best of McKinney – 2025
In 2025, we were honored by BusinessRate as the top insurance agency in McKinney. This award reflects our ongoing commitment to excellence and community-focused service.
ThreeBestRated – Best Insurance Agency of McKinney 2025
Also in 2025, ThreeBestRated recognized us as one of the best insurance agencies in McKinney, reinforcing our reputation for quality, trust, and exceptional service.
D Magazine Recognitions – 2018 & 2024
We were honored by D Magazine in both 2018 and 2024, highlighting our professional achievements and reputation as one of McKinney’s top insurance professionals.
Together, these awards highlight not just our achievements, but the strong relationships we build with our clients—because at Mauceri Bynum Insurance, our community comes first.
Contact Us!